Interview with Investing News on U.S. midterm election day, November 4, 2026

John Feneck, portfolio manager and consultant at Feneck Consulting, told Investing News that gold's break below $4,000 and silver's slide beneath $50 have changed the technical picture for precious metals, and that he is not adding exposure until the midterm results and the next batch of macro data are known. His message was candid. The September stability in gold has gone, a month-end close below support is "not positive" from a chart perspective, and the August rally in mining equities, which he called "amazing price action," did not hold.

Gold Loses Its Floor, and Feneck Admits Silver Was Not Sold Aggressively Enough

Gold fell through the prior low of $3,941 and traded below $3,900, which Feneck described as concerning because it "opens further downside risk." He had told audiences throughout late summer to expect a test of $3,900 to $4,000. He noted that Goldman Sachs and Bank of America had called for gold near $5,000 by year-end, and that he could find no sign Goldman had withdrawn its $4,900 forecast. "A thousand points in 7 weeks is a tall order, but I hope they're right," he said. Both metals closed October at levels he considers technically weak.

Silver was Feneck's largest holding, and he was blunt about the damage. The metal reached $121 in the first quarter and is now below $50, a drop of almost 60% from the peak within one year. "It's very, very destructive to people's portfolios, including mine," he said. His firm sold about 20% of its silver above $100 in the first quarter, as he had said it would, but he conceded "we should have sold more." After 26 years following the metal, he said he had expected silver to hold an elevated range and instead saw a blow-off top. He also pointed to a roughly 34% one-day decline at the end of January, which he suggested involved collusion on the short side. He noted that JPMorgan and other institutions have been fined for silver manipulation in the past, and he criticized regulators in the sector as "one-way street" watchers: "If there's negative action, it's fine. If there's positive action, the regulators want to know, why is your stock up?"

On levels, Feneck said his firm will be a buyer of silver again in the $45 to $50 range. That is the breakout zone from the 1980s and 2011-12, which silver cleared "like butter" last year. He is not buying today, though, and described his stance as "on the sidelines until we see what happens and how it's perceived." He puts the "bottom bottom" at the high $30s for silver and $3,500 for gold, and does not expect those levels to break. He cautioned that if the metals did trade there, miners would fall considerably further.

Midterms, a Possible December Hike and a Market Feneck Calls "Sick"

Feneck made the midterm elections his central near-term variable. He cited roughly a 30% probability of Republicans winning the Senate as of an hour before the interview, up from earlier readings, and said he believes further downside in the sector is likely if Republicans lose both chambers. "I don't think it's all factored in yet," he said. A Republican win on any front would be received well by broad equities, in his view, because "it's like a sick patient that just wants drugs." In the longer term he thinks political turmoil, including a possible contested result or renewed military action against Iran, would favor gold and silver, but he warned of continued volatility and possible additional tax-loss selling in the sector.

On the Fed, he noted markets were pricing a 74% probability of a 25 basis point hike on December 9 as of last week's meeting, and he thinks the odds remain above 50%. He regards a single hike as largely priced in. His concern is a repeat next year. "What I do think is destructive is if we get another four hikes next year," he said, adding that only a few banks are calling for that and that he thinks they are "crazy." He flagged the November 6 nonfarm payrolls report and the November 10 CPI release as the next inputs, noting the Fed has said repeatedly since June that inflation is its priority.

Feneck sees equity weakness spreading beyond metals. He pointed to Intel falling 28% in a day, its largest one-day loss ever, and Alphabet dropping nearly 13% on its earnings day, also a record. He added that Amazon was up only about 5% year to date as of last week, a return "you can get in a money market fund." S&P 500 breadth is as narrow as he has seen since 2008-09, with a handful of stocks carrying index performance. "The easy money scenario for AI and tech is coming to a close," he said, calling the recent declines "the beginning" of a broader flush. He said trading is now heavily algorithmic and difficult to navigate even for professionals, and he urged investors to get advice. He also said most people's savings sit in retirement accounts and index funds rather than mining stocks, and that anyone whose portfolio is dominated by miners should reassess their risk tolerance.

GDX Holds the Key Support Zone, and Large-Cap Earnings Are Being Overlooked

Feneck used the VanEck Gold Miners ETF, GDX, to illustrate how fast the sector moved. The fund rose from about $70 to $105 between August 3 and August 28, after bouncing off the $68 to $70 zone his firm had identified as necessary support. It now trades near $78. He said a retest of $68 to $70 is possible and that a failure there would require a look at longer-dated charts for the next support.

He offered one constructive observation. Newmont and Agnico Eagle, the two largest GDX holdings, both reported strong earnings, which he said is bullish but "just sort of being put to the side right now" while investors wait on the election and the Fed. He pointed to leverage as the reason he prefers equities to bullion. A silver move from $50 to $60 yields 20%, whereas silver juniors and seniors typically deliver two to three times that sensitivity. That cuts both ways, as the past two months have shown....