Panel discussion with Tavi Costa of Azuria Capital and Craig Hemke of the TF Metals Report, Vancouver Resource Investment Conference, November 19, 2026
Two precious metals investors laid out contrasting tactics at a VRIC Media panel after a sharp sell-off. Costa is deploying capital now and Hemke is holding cash and waiting. Both argue the fundamentals behind gold and silver have not changed. Gold fell below $3,900 an ounce the day before the discussion, and silver trades in the $40s. The metals dumped while the panelists were at the New Orleans Investment Conference at the end of October, bounced into the week of November 9, then rolled over again.
Costa: the key question is mid-cycle correction versus end of a secular bull market
Costa said the most relevant question for investors is whether the current decline is a mid-cycle correction or the end of a secular bull market. He sides with the former. "I've never seen a secular bull market that ended with no extra new supply, that didn't end with total complete leverage across the entire industry, with margins that are actually not as great as you think, with positioning across most metals very heavily one-sided, sentiment completely different, and in particular the M&A cycle," he said. He noted that none of those conditions are present, and that there have been no discoveries.
He framed the setup as asymmetric. Silver could fall to $35 or $40, or re-establish itself at $75 or $80. "Even at a $35, $40 silver price, it's not the end of the world for the silver companies that are high quality," he said. Some companies are already down 75% to 80%, which he called "a hell of a correction". He said he does not know whether prices bounce this week or next, but that 12-month and 24-month windows look "very attractive".
Costa pointed to several technical signs of exhaustion. Almost 0% of silver miners trade above their 200-day moving average. Silver's distance from its own 200-day average is as stretched as in the 2020 crash. Silver miners are now outperforming silver, and gold miners are starting to outperform gold. He described the selling in the riskier parts of the market as "fatigue" and said the froth is gone. He also considers the dollar "so overvalued".
On macro, Costa believes the Fed is near the end of its hiking cycle. He allowed for a 50 basis point increase but doubted much more would follow, given a decelerating economy and equal-weighted commodity prices that are "down pretty good". He called commodities "the right metric to look at inflation". He said conditions across commodities, gold, silver and hard assets are "very oversold", and that "we haven't seen the turn yet but we're getting to very critical oversold levels".
Silver miners hold $4 billion to $5 billion in cash and could be forced to act
Costa's most distinctive argument concerned silver sector balance sheets. Silver miners hold roughly $4 billion to $5 billion in cash, he said, and when he asks CEOs why, the usual answer is that they have been through cycles before and want to be careful. He appreciates the conservatism. He added that these executives still see valuations as expensive, since the companies were worth perhaps a quarter of current prices two to three years ago.
His thesis is that the cash could become a problem if silver rebounds. He estimated the group will accumulate about $7 billion over the next 12 months. "They can't just be holding that much cash. It's too much," he said. If prices bounce, the window to buy assets cheaply closes, and the companies would have to acquire at higher valuations or buy back shares. He called that "financial engineering 101 on the back of a good silver market".
Costa also stressed how few silver equities exist. Holders such as Sprott are long-term and rarely sell. He said that if investors take just 10% to 15% of the float, they are in effect taking about 30% of the float actually available. "I think there's going to be a lot of capital chasing silver equities, and there are not many silver equities out there," he said, while acknowledging it is a thesis he has been working on and he may be wrong.
His own portfolio is about 65% silver miners, with the remainder mostly in gold and "barely any copper". He said silver miners are "way less risky than three years ago", given much larger cash balances. He also likes mid-tier producers and cashed-up developers.
Hemke: futures-driven selling, December expiry and a gold buy level
Hemke described a broader risk-off tone. Bitcoin is down 20% from its recent highs, silver and gold are making lower lows after the CPI release and subsequent Fed commentary, and stocks are starting to roll over. He said it is not a full-on liquidation or margin call event, "but the trend is still lower. And sometimes you just got to get out of the way."
He argued the decline is futures-driven rather than physical. The selling is concentrated in US trading hours, and December silver has gone into backwardation against spot. He said that was "extreme enough" to hope for a washout once December contract expirations pass in about two weeks. He also expects fading expectations of rate hikes beyond December, the typically strong December and January seasonality, and tax-loss selling in the first weeks of December to be relevant. "I keep thinking, well, that's about as bad as it's going to get. It gets worse," he said....